Using "Save for Web" will automatically decrease the resolution of your graphic to 72 DPI. This will result in a smaller image, lower quality, and will not perfectly fit in our editor if you're using our design templates.
Therefor we always recommend to use "Save As..." within Illustrator and Photoshop to maintain the highest quality of your file.
Simply click on File → Save As... and save your file in either PNG or JPEG at the highest quality settings.